Advertisement

Prevalence, impact and management of dysmenorrhea among female students in a Nigerian University

Research Article | DOI: https://doi.org/10.31579/2835-8325/085

Prevalence, impact and management of dysmenorrhea among female students in a Nigerian University

  • Nkeiruka Grace Osuafor 1
  • Adaora Venessa Ibezimakor 1
  • Godswill NwabisiOsuafor 1
  • Brianonyebuchi Ogbonna 2,3*

1Department of Clinical Pharmacy and Pharmacy Practice, Faculty of Pharmacy, Madona University, Elele, Nigeria

2Department of Clinical Pharmacy and Pharmacy Management, Faculty of Pharmaceutical Sciences, NnamdiAzikiwe University, Awka, Nigeria

3Department of Clinical Pharmacy and Pharmacy Practice, Faculty of Pharmacy, David Umahi Federal University of Health Sciences, Uburu, Nigeria

*Corresponding Author: Ogbonna Brian O, Department of Clinical Pharmacy and Pharmacy Management, Faculty of Pharmaceutical Sciences, NnamdiAzikiwe University, Awka, Nigeria Department of Clinical Pharmacy and Pharmacy Practice, Faculty of Pharmacy, David Umahi Federal Universit

Citation: Nkeiruka Grace Osuafor, Adaora Venessa Ibezimakor, Godswill NwabisiOsuafor, Brianonyebuchi Ogbonna, (2024), Prevalence, impact and management of dysmenorrhea among female students in a Nigerian University”; Clinical research and Clinical reports 5(1): DOI: 10.31579/2835-8325/085

Copyright: © 2024, Brianonyebuchi Ogbonna. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Received: 11 September 2024 | Accepted: 25 September 2024 | Published: 09 October 2024

Keywords: dysmenorrloea,menarche; university students; menstruation; nigeria

Abstract

Background and Objective:The exact prevalence of dysmenorrhea and it’s severity is difficult to determine because sociodemographic characteristics disperities and genetic variations. The study assessed the prevalence, impact and management of dysmenorrhea among female undergraduateNigerian students.

Methods:The study was a descriptive cross-sectional study carried out in Madonna University, Elele campus, Rivers state between February to April 2023.

Results: Three hundred and ninety (390) questionnaires were valid and included in the final analysis, giving a response rate of (97.5%). The average age of study respondents was 22.81±33 years and majority (221, 56.7%) were between 21-25 years.The minimum and maximum menarche age was nine (9) and 15 years respectively with ameanmenarcheageof12.23±14.Predictors of presence of dysmenorrhea, use of non-pharmacological and pharmacological management Inferential statistics revealed that level of study (OR 1.003, {P= 0.021, CI 1.000-1.006}), family history of dysmenorrhea (OR = 4.817, {P <0.001, CI 2.998-7.739}) and longer flow duration (OR = 21.931, {P =0.004, CI = 2.717-176.99}) significantly predicted the presence of dysmenorrhea.

Conclusion: A half of the studentsexperience dysmenorrhea. Majority of the students resorted to social withdrawal, and experiences altered sleep pattern and changes in their appetite.Hot water therapy was applied as a non-pharmacological method for managing pain and most student use a combination of pharmacological and non-pharmacological methods to manage their pain. NSAID is the most used pharmacological approach

Introduction

Menstruation is a natural discharge of blood, secretions and tissue debris from the womb at approximately monthly intervals throughout the reproductive years of females [1]. Some females experience abnormal flow termed dysmenorrhea which is a painful sensation that occurs at lower abdominal region and pubic bone before and/or during menstruation [2]. The pain is usually accompanied by physical and biological symptoms that includes nausea, vomiting, fatigue, serious headache [3]. Dysmenorrhea is one of the most frequent gynecological diseases reported among women of reproductive age [4,5]. 

A number of studies have estimated the prevalence of dysmenorrhea in Nigeria and globally [1,6–9]. The prevalence of dysmenorrhea in Nigeria ranges from 51.1% [6]- 76.3% [8]. Around the world, Romania, reported a prevalence of 78.4 while a Malaysia study documented 87.3% [4]. The exact prevalence of dysmenorrhea and it’s severity is difficult to determine because sociodemographic characteristics, family financial condition and genetic factors may affect presence of dysmenorrhea [1,2]. In Nigeria, age, duration of menstrual flow, body mass index, use of oral contraceptives, good dietary pattern showed association with presence of dysmenorrhea [7,9,11]. Long menstrual cycle interval, long menses flows, positive family history, lower chronical/gynecological age and alcohol use increased the presence and severity of dysmenorrhea [1,2]. In a Jordan study, severe dysmenorrhea was significantly associated with women who never eat meat, those who consume cereals and fish and those who eat less than three servings of fruit per week [12]. Less than 20 years of age, early menarche,lack of physical activity, depression, smoking, anxiety, nulliparity, higher socioeconomicstatus,heavymenses and familyhistoryof dysmenorrhea were also reported as risk factors to dysmenorrhea [13].

Presence of dysmenorrhea comes with discomforts which may impact negatively on health, social life and occupational roles of affected women. Academic work may come with additional stress and a study documented increase in severity of menstrual pain with strenuous activities [10]. In Greece, the pain experienced during menstruation amplifies feeling of nervousness and weakness, decreases energy levels, concentration in course work and the extent of volume of information that can be acquired among students [14]. Dysmenorrhea also affected outdoor activities, clothing choice of students social life, couples relationship and interaction with family members10. Dysmenorrhea caused mobility problems, decreased personal care, depression and anxiety. Women with dysmenorrhea had a significantly lower perception of their quality of life compared to other group15. However, impact of dysmenorrhea on students of Madonna University has never be put in context.

Students in higher institution leaving away from home may experience a greater burden of the symptoms of dysmenorrhea. Consequently, different treatments including pharmacological and non-pharmacological approaches have been applied to manage dysmenorrhea. Since, pain is mediated by prostaglandin, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDS), which inhibits the synthesis of prostaglandin is considered an effective pharmacological treatment [16]. Oral contraceptive pills are also recommended for management of dysmenorrhea when NSAIDS have failed after three episodes of dysmenorrhea [3]. Non pharmacological therapy like yoga, meditation, acupuncture have been used to lessen the effects of dysmenorrhea [1]. Some home therapies like hot water massage, drinking fluids like water, tea, coca cola have also been used to alleviate pain of dysmenorrhea [1,3]. In Nigeria, 31% of students that experience dysmenorrhea took drugs while 24.9% did nothing [6]. A study done in Northern Ethiopia revealed that 48% of the participants took ibuprofen [3]. Paracetamol, an antipyretic agent was the most consumed (41.3%) drug for managing dysmenorrhea pain in Northern Ghana not minding the severity of pain [2]. 

However, the prevalence, impact and management of dysmenorrhea has not been described in Madonna University Nigeria. The students spend most of their time inside the school as it is compulsory to live and attend classes within the school environment. Some female students may suffer from dysmenorrhea which will reduce their participation in school activities and may lead to extension of the number of academic years they stay in the school. This has a consequence not only on the student but on the family due to the financial burden of continuous stay in the university. The study assessed the prevalence, impact and management of dysmenorrhea among female undergraduate students of Madonna University Elele, Nigeria.

Methods

Study design:The study was a descriptive cross-sectional study carried out in Madonna University, Elele campus, Rivers state between February to April 2023. 

Study population and sample size:The population was 6195 female undergraduate students admitted in the school in the 2021/2022 academic session. A sample size of 361 female students was calculated at precision level of 5% and 95% confidence interval. To account for non-response, 10% 17 of the sample size was added yielding 398. 

Study criteria: We sampled the female undergraduate and registered studens who gave their informed consent to participate in the study and available at the time of the study. We excluded those who were qualified but absent at the time of data collection.

Sampling method: The students were sampled from the eight female hostels using systematic random sampling. The hostels differ in terms of capacity, therefore the number of students sampled from the hostels was a ratio of number of students in the hostel multiplied by the required sample size. The number of girls in a room determined the number of rooms that was sampled from the hostel. All the girls living in the sampled room were invited to participate in the study.

Study instrument handling: A self-administered questionnaire prepared in English Language as that is the language of instruction in Madonna University was used for data collection. The questionnaire was developed after review of previous works on dysmenorrhea [2,4,18]. It was read and corrected by experts in questionnaire design and pretested among thirty-pre-degree students not included in the final analysis. The questionnaire was again reviewed by experts and necessary corrections were made before it was administered to respondents. Four parts was recognized in the questionnaire, the sociodemographic characteristics, menstruation details, impact and management of dysmenorrhea. Oral consent was sought and obtained from the students before handing out the questionnaire. 

Data analysis:The data was analysed with descriptive and inferential statistics using SPSS version 25. All collected data were described and binary logistic regression was used to predict presence of dysmenorrhea, use of pharmacological treatment and use of non pharmacological treatment.

Results

Sociodemographic and menstrual characteristics

Most of the respondents were single (n=360, 92.3%) and a higher proportion (98, 25.1) had spent a minimum of five years in school. Lowerthanhalfoftherespondents42.3%reportedhaving a family history of dysmenorrhea. Table 1 shows the detailsof demographic variables.

 

Age (years)

Frequency

Percent

(%)

16-20

121

31.8

21-25

221

56.7

26-30

45

11.5

Menarche age (years)

 

 

9-12

238

61

13-15

152

39

Marital Status

 

 

Single

360

92.3

Married

30

7.7

Level of study

 

 

100

35

9

200

57

14.6

300

41

10.5

400

70

17.9

500

98

25.1

600

89

22.8

Family history of dysmenorrhea

 

 

No

225

57.7

Yes

165

42.3

 

Table 1: Sociodemographic characteristics of the respondents 

Prevalence of dysmenorrhea and menstrual characteristics 

Approximately half (n =191, 49%) reported having menstrual pain, with pain occurring atonsetofmenstruationfor72.8% (139) oftherespondents. Ninetyone(n=91,47.6%) of respondents with dysmenorrhea described the pain as severe while a higher proportion (n =134, 70.2%) recognized the pain as continuous in nature andmore than half (n= 202, 51.8%) have menstrual flow duration of ≥5 days. Table 2 presents the details ofprevalenceandcharacteristics ofdysmenorrheaamongthe respondents. 

Menstrual Pain present

 

n

(%)

Yes  

191

49

No

199

51

Onset of pain

 

 

Before menstruation

32

16.8

Onset of menstruation

139

72.8

A day after onset of menstruation

20

10.5

Description of Pain

 

 

Mild

36

18.8

Moderate

64

33.5

Severe  

91

47.6

Pain type

 

 

Intermittent

57

29.8

Continuous

134

70.2

Flow duration

 

 

1-2 days

23

5.9

3-4 days

165

42.3

5 and more days

202

51.8

 

Table 2: Prevalence of dysmenorrhea and menstrual characteristics 

Table 3 shows the impact of dysmenorrhea. Out of the respondents, 79.6% reported theyexperienced social withdrawal and lack of concentration in their academic work (56.5%). In association with this,51% reported being absent from classes. Also, 62.3% reported decreased appetite and 60.7%reportedachangein sleep pattern dueto dysmenorrhea. For most of the respondents, the pain starts at the onset of menstruration

Experience social withdrawal

(n)

 (%)

Yes

152

79.6

No

39

20.4

Lack concentration

 

 

Yes  

108

56.5

No

83

43.5

Altered Sleep pattern

 

 

Yes  

116

60.7

No

75

39.3

Change in appetite

 

 

Yes  

119

62.3

No

72

37.7

Absenteeism 

 

 

Yes

98

51

No

94

49

Table 3: Impact of dysmenorrhea on daily activities 

Table4showsthe respondents managementpatternofdysmenorrhea and their knowledge of the medications they use. Most (91, 47.6%) of them managed dysmenorrhea with a combination of pharmacological and non pharmacological therapy. Considering the non-pharmacological therapies, n = 67, 35.1% used hot water alone to easetheirpain, otherscombinemorethanonemethodofnon-pharmacologicaltherapieswhilen=77, 40.3%did not applyanynon pharmacological therapy. Mostrespondentswithdysmenorrhea (85.8%) utilizedmedicationstomanagetheirpain. More than a quarter of the respondents (27.7%), used (NSAIDs) as a single agent in managingtheir pain. Antipyretics alone were utilized by 19.4% of the respondents. Almost half of the respondents 49.2% took their medications two times a day. A high proportion (151, 92.1%) has knowledge on the harmful effects of the drug used. 

Considering the management pattern and pain severity, almost half of the respondents that reported severe pain used one form of pharmacological therapy compared to 44% of students with mild pain that used non pharmacological therapy. Table 5 details the relationship between treatment and severity of pain.

Variables

Frequency

(n)

Percentage

(%)

No form of treatment

4

2.1

Non pharmacological treatment

23

12

Pharmacological treatment

73

38.2

Both treatment

91

47.6

Non-Pharmacological therapy

 

 

Hot water

67

35.1

Aroma therapy

8

4.2

Aroma therapy and hot water

17

8.9

Exercise  

10

5.2

Hot water and exercise

12

6.3

No non pharmacological therapy

77

40.3

Pharmacological therapy

 

 

(Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDS)

57

27.7

Antipyretic

37

19.4

Hormonal contraceptive

26

13.6

NSAIDS and hormonal contraceptives

19

9.9

NSAIDS and supplements

12

6.3

Antipyretic and supplements

6

3.1

Antipyretic and NSAIDS

11

5.8

No treatment

27

14.1

Frequency of drug use

 

 

1-2 times daily

94

49.2

3-4 times daily

35

18.3

When necessary

35

18.3

No drug therapy

27

14.1

Knowledge on harmful effects of the drug

 

 

Yes

151

92.1

No

13

7.9

Knowledge on contraindication

 

 

Yes

143

87.2

No

21

12.8

Knowledge on maximum dose of the drug

 

 

Yes

156

95.1

No

8

4.9

Knowledge on the adverse effects of the drug

 

 

Yes  

145

88.4

No

19

11.6

 

Table 4: Management of dysmenorrhea and knowledge on drug therapy by the respondents 

Type of treatment

Mild 

n (%)

Moderate

n (%)

Severe 

N (%)

P-Value (X2)

No treatment 

1 (2.8)

1 (1.6)

2 (2.2)

<0>

Pharmacological treatment

9 (25)

19 (29.7)

45 (49.5)

 

Non pharmacological treatment

16 (44.4)

6 (9.4)

19 (1.1)

 

Pharmacological and non-pharmacological

10 (27.8)

38 (59.4)

43 (47.3)

 

Total  

36(100)

64(100)

91(100)

 

Table 5: Relationship between type of treatment and pain severity

Respondents with severe pain (OR = 0.379, {P =0.038, 0.152-0.947}) had increased odds of using non pharmacological therapy. Having a severe (OR= 37.340, P = < 0 OR=0.092, P=0.009, CI=0.16-0.54)>

Presence of dysmenorrhea

 

Predicting variables

OR

P- value

95% CI

Demographic Variables

 

 

 

Age (years)

 

 

 

16-24 (Ref) 

 

 

 

21-25

0.729

0.494

0.295-1.801

26-30

0.325

0.074

0.095-1.116

Level of study

1.003

0.021*

1.000-1.006

Menarche age (years)

 

 

 

9-12 (Ref)

 

 

 

13-15

0.857

0.464

0.520-1.348

Family history of dysmenorrhea

 

 

 

No (Reference category)

 

 

 

Yes

4.817

<0>

2.998-7.739

Flow duration

 

 

 

1-2 days (Ref)

 

 

 

3-4 days

10.619

0.026*

1.330-84.754

5 and more days

21.931

0.004*

2.717-176.995

 Use of non-pharmacological agent

Description of pain

 

 

 

Mild

-

 

 

Moderate

0.878

0.791

0.334-2.306

Severe

0.379

0.038*

0.152-0.947

Onset of pain

 

 

 

Before menstruation

 

 

 

Onset of menstruation

0.449

0.104

0.171-1.178

A day after onset of menstruation

0.291

0.057

0.082-1.035

Type of pain

 

 

 

Intermittent

 

 

 

Continuous

0.707

0.336

0.349-1.434

Level of study

1.000

0.906

0.998-1.002

Use of pharmacological agent

Description of pain

 

 

 

Mild

 

 

 

Moderate

8.691

0.01*

2.510-30.090

Severe

37.340

<0>

8.019-173.863

Onset of pain

 

 

 

Before menstruation

 

 

 

Onset of menstruation

1.308

0.718

0.304-5.627

A day after onset of menstruation

1.217

0.846

0.167-8.851

Type of pain

 

 

 

Intermittent

Reference  

 

 

Continuous

0.092

0.009*

0.16-0.548

Level of study

0.999

0.728

0.996-1.003

Table 6: Predictors of presence of dysmenorrhea, andthe use of non-pharmacological and pharmacological agent

Discussion

The study investigated prevalence, impact and management of dysmenorrhea in Madonna University Elele, Nigeria. The prevalence of dysmenorrhea in the present study was 49%, which is similar to 51.1% [6] and 53.3% [7], reported in previous Nigeria studies. Although, higher prevalence 76.3% [8], 73% [9] and 68.8% [11] has been reported in other Nigerian studies. Published work around the world, reported prevalence of dysmenorrhea to be 89.2% in Greece, 71.8% in Ethiopia and 63.5% in Jordan [3,12,14]. The differences in the prevalence might be related to the pain perception and interpretation by the females as no scale was used to ascertain the presence of pain. For most of the students in this study, the onset of the pain was at the beginning of the menstrual cycle which contradicts report of pain starting before blood flow in Northern Ghana [2].  Respondents experiencing severe pain were higher than moderate and mild pain. This is in line with reports byVlachouet al., in Greece [14]. However, a Ghana [2] study reported moderate pain as the major pain type experienced by the respondents. variability in individual pain threshold influenced by genetics, psychology, social and cultural beliefs might affect the interpretation of pain2. Therefore, the different pain types expressed by the respondents in these studies is based on their interpretation of pain.

Our study indicated that dysmenorrhea impacted negatively on the activities of most of the students, which has been documented by several reports1–3 around the globe. Notably, social withdrawal affected a greater proportion of the students while 56% lacked concentration. In a study conducted among university students in Northern Ghana, dysmenorrhea impacted on attendance of lectures (70.7%) of the respondents and 44.2% of them lacked concentration. However, a study among nursing students in Spain indicated that dysmenorrhea affected the daily activities of a few proportion 5.6% of the participants [15]. The differences might lie on individual capability of the respondents to carry on with activities while in pain. Absenteeism affected only 51% of the students in this present study, which is lower than other Nigerian reports of 79.3% among secondary school girls and 66% in private universities [5,11]. The report in our study may be expected as hostels are locked after students leave for lectures Madonna University. It might suggest that most of them may not want to be locked inside the hostel.

Only a few persons (2.1%) did not take any form of therapy to alleviate their menstruation pain which is lower than another report from Nigeria (24.9%). Use of warm water was the most non pharmacological treatment applied to manage dysmenorrhea in this study similar to a Romanian study10. The present study recorded a lower proportion (5.2%) using exercise as a means to reduce pain compared to a 25.3% recorded in a previous Nigeria study9. Although there are records [19,4], that exercise may relieve dysmenorrhea pain, other studies still question the authenticity of the claim [20]. More than two third of girls with dysmenorrhea utilized one form of pharmacology therapy. 

The most utilized medication for managing dysmenorrhea pain in this study was NSAIDs. This was reported in other studies across the globe [1,3,14,18]. This is expected for the fact that NSAIDs reduce pain that results from prostaglandin activity and there is increased prostaglandin synthesis in the endometrium during menstrual period [21].  Also, there is support of NSAIDs as a first line in the management of primary dysmenorrhea [22]. The prostaglandin is said to mediate uterine contraction which increases pain sensation during menstrual period [1]. Most of the students had knowledge on the side effects, maximum dose, contraindications and harmful effects of the drug compared to an Ethiopian study [1]. The result is expected as most of the students are in pharmacy, medical and nursing department. Notwithstanding, every use of NSAIDs and contraceptive should be aware of harms associated with the use.

The present study did not find a significant association between age, menarche age and the presence of dysmenorrhea. However, having a family history of dysmenorrhea and longer days of menstrual flow duration predicted presence of dysmenorrhea in these students which is similar to other studies [1,13]. How the respondents interpreted their severity and type of pain affected the use of pharmacological and non pharmacological agent. People that reported moderate to severe pain and continuous pain type used non pharmacological and pharmacological therapy similar to reports from other African countries [1,3]. The result is expected as intense feeling of pain will propel one to seek solution as compared to people with mild and intermittent pain.

Conclusion

Half of the population of female students experience dysmenorrhea, which impacts negatively on their academic and social engagements. Hot water therapy was applied as a non-pharmacological method for managing pain and most student use a combination of pharmacological and non-pharmacological methods to manage their pain. NSAID is the most used pharmacological approach for managing dysmenorrhea pain among them. We recommend school management include this question on presence of painful menstruation on school admission form to identify students that might need some consideration if they miss school activities during menstrual periods.

Conflict' of interest: The authors have none to declare.

Funding: None was received.

References

Clinical Trials and Clinical Research: I am delighted to provide a testimonial for the peer review process, support from the editorial office, and the exceptional quality of the journal for my article entitled “Effect of Traditional Moxibustion in Assisting the Rehabilitation of Stroke Patients.” The peer review process for my article was rigorous and thorough, ensuring that only high-quality research is published in the journal. The reviewers provided valuable feedback and constructive criticism that greatly improved the clarity and scientific rigor of my study. Their expertise and attention to detail helped me refine my research methodology and strengthen the overall impact of my findings. I would also like to express my gratitude for the exceptional support I received from the editorial office throughout the publication process. The editorial team was prompt, professional, and highly responsive to all my queries and concerns. Their guidance and assistance were instrumental in navigating the submission and revision process, making it a seamless and efficient experience. Furthermore, I am impressed by the outstanding quality of the journal itself. The journal’s commitment to publishing cutting-edge research in the field of stroke rehabilitation is evident in the diverse range of articles it features. The journal consistently upholds rigorous scientific standards, ensuring that only the most impactful and innovative studies are published. This commitment to excellence has undoubtedly contributed to the journal’s reputation as a leading platform for stroke rehabilitation research. In conclusion, I am extremely satisfied with the peer review process, the support from the editorial office, and the overall quality of the journal for my article. I wholeheartedly recommend this journal to researchers and clinicians interested in stroke rehabilitation and related fields. The journal’s dedication to scientific rigor, coupled with the exceptional support provided by the editorial office, makes it an invaluable platform for disseminating research and advancing the field.

img

Dr Shiming Tang

Clinical Reviews and Case Reports, The comment form the peer-review were satisfactory. I will cements on the quality of the journal when I receive my hardback copy

img

Hameed khan