Review Article | DOI: https://doi.org/10.31579/2834-796X/031
Critical Analysis of Some Cardiac Disorders in Ayurveda Vigyan in Modern Perspective
1 HOD – Dept. of Roga Nidana & Vikruti Vigyana Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan College of Ayurveda & Research Center, SRK University, Bhopal – 462 047 (M.P.) (India)
2 Asst Prof.– Dept. of Roga Nidana & Vikruti Vigyana Government Ayurved College, Nanded – 431601.
*Corresponding Author: Subhash Waghe, HOD – Dept. of Roga Nidana & Vikruti Vigyana Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan College of Ayurveda & Research Center, SRK University, Bhopal – 462 047 (M.P.) (India).
Citation: Subhash Waghe, Hemant Panchade, (2023), Critical Analysis of Some Cardiac Disorders in Ayurveda Vigyan in Modern Perspective, International Journal of Cardiovascular Medicine, 2(2); DOI:10.31579/2834-796X/031
Copyright: © 2023, Subhash Waghe. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Received: 03 April 2023 | Accepted: 17 April 2023 | Published: 24 April 2023
Keywords: heart disease; vikshepika; ayamika; pruthuka
Abstract
Ayurveda is a ancient Indian medical science. Many scholars like Charaka, Sushruta (155BC), Vagbhata, Madhav Kara, Sharngdhar, Bhav Mishra (450 AD to 1650 AD) etc have contributed immensely in the enrichment of Ayurvedic literature. In the late 19th century authors like Vinodlal sen, Gananath Sen, Gangadhar Roy etc have contributed in updating the Ayurvedic literature with time. Although we find description of heart disease in the form of acute coronary syndrome in classical Ayurvedic texts, but the description of other entities is obscure. In the book called ‘Ayurved Vigyana’ written by Vinodlal Sen (1870 -1910 AD), there is description of five different types of cardiac disorders, Viz. 1. Vikshepika 2. Aayamika, 3. Pruthuka 4. Medasutra and 5. Parikshaya. Attempt has been made to study critically these disorders in the modern perspective. It is observed and concluded that disease Vikshepika corresponds to acute coronary syndrome in modern science. Disease Aayamika matches with the syndrome of cardiomegaly and heart failure. Disease Pruthuka coincides with hypertrophic cardiomyopathy in modern science. Disease Medasutra can be called as the fatty degeneration of heart as per modern science. Disease Parikshaya is the degenerative diseases of heart.
Introduction
Cardiac diseases are on sharp rise across the globe due to various reasons. Acute coronary syndrome, heart failure, hypertrophic cardiomyopathies are routinely encountered. Hence, it become essential to look for reference of these disorders in ancient medical science. Ayurveda is ancient Indian medical science. Many scholars like Charaka, Sushruta (155BC), Vagbhata, Madhav Kara, Sharngdhar, Bhav Mishra (450 AD to 1650 AD) etc have contributed immensely in the enrichment of Ayurvedic literature. In the late 19th century authors like Vinodlal sen, Gananath Sen, Gangadhar Roy etc have contributed in upadating the Ayurvedic literature with time. Although we find description of heart disease in the form of acute coronary syndrome in classical Ayurvedic texts, but the description of other entities is obscure. In the book called ‘Ayurved Vigyana’ written by Vinodlal Sen (1870 -1910 AD), there is description of five different types of cardiac disorders, Viz. 1. Vikshepika 2. Aayamika, 3. Pruthuka 4. Medasutra and 5. Parikshaya. Attempt has been made to study critically these disorders in the modern perspective.
Review of Literature
1. Vikshepika
Clinical Features [1]
• Severe chest pain
• Pain radiation to neck and back
• Pricking or burning pain
• Palpitations
• Breathlessness
• Sweating
• Cyanosis
• Altered consciousness
• Cold skin
• Death
Prognosis :
Bad if not treated early
2. Ayamika
‘Aayam’ literally mean ‘stretching’(enlargement). In the disease ‘Aayamika’, there is chamber enlargement of the heart.
Clinical Features [2]
• Dyspnea
• Palpitations
• Giddiness
• Syncope
• Insomnia
• Anorexia
• Ascites
• Weakness
• Cahexia
3. PRUTHUKA
The heart disease ‘Pruthuk” mentioned in ‘Ayurved Vigyan’ by Vinodlal Sen refers to the hypertrophy of the heart.
Aetiology
Same as the causes responsible for dilatation of the heart.
Pathogenesis
There is cardiac chamber hypertrophy following dilatation of the heart.
Clinical Features [3]
• Palpitations
• Cyanosis
• Breathlessness
• Weakness
• Vertigo
• Confusion
4. Kaushthika
The heart disease ‘KaushthikaHa” mentioned in ‘Ayurved Vigyan’ by Vinodlal Sen refers to the infection and inflammation of the endocardium of the heart.
Aetiology:
• Rheumatic Heart Disease
• Chest trauma
• Pericardial effusion
Pathogenesis
There is cardiac chamber enlargement due to above causes
Clinical Features [4]
• Palpitations
• Cyanosis
• Breathlessness
• Cough
• Fever
• Weakness
• Vertigo
• Irregular appetite
• Gradual edema feet
• Syncope
• Convulsions
• Irregular Pulse
Prognois :
Very bad. Hardly any survives by luck.
But with advent of powerful antibiotics this condition is treatable now. Hence, same will be discussed in modern view of this disease.
5. Aavaranika
Aetiology
• Rheumatic Fever
• Renal diseases
• Consumption of cold food, beverages and cold environment.
In the above aetiology, Aamvata refers to rheumatic heart disease secondary to rheumatic fever. Renal diseases leading to uremia may cause pericardial effusion. Consumption of cold food and beverages and cold environment may indicate towards viral aetiology.
Pathogenesis
• The above aetiology, affects the pericardium due to lack of treatment.
• Rheumatic fever pathology causes inflammation in heart and its valves.
• And thereby leads to collection of fluid in the pericardial sac.
Clinical Features [5]
• Burning in chest
• Fever
• Acute chest pain
• Heart fibrillation
• Dyspnoea
• Cough
• Nasal bleed
• Weakness
• Anorexia
• Edema feet
Investigation
• Irregular pulse
Treatment
• It should not be neglected and be treated on priority.
• Ratnakar Rasa 500 mg tid
6. Medasutram
The heart disease ‘Medsutram” mentioned in ‘Ayurved Vigyan’ by Vinodlal Sen refers to the fatty degeneration of the heart.
Aetiology
Consumption of fat rich foods
Pathogenesis
In this disease fat droplets gets deposited in heart muscles.
Clinical Features [6]
• Palpitations
• Weakness
• Vertigo
• Syncope
• Slow pulse
• Depression
• Heart muscle weakness
• Rupture of heart
Prognosis:
Bad if not treated early
7. Parikshaya
The heart disease ‘Pari Kshaya” mentioned in ‘Ayurved Vigyan’ by Vinodlal Sen refers to the atrophy of the heart muscles.
Aetiology
It occurs due to all the causes leading to emaciation.
Pathogenesis
The atrophy of heart muscles occurs
Clinical features [7]
• Palpitations
• Breathlessness
• Weakness
• Vertigo
• Anorexia
• Gradual edema feet
• other features may also occur.
Treatment:
Symptomatic
Rest and restriction of physical activities
The healthy, good nutrition.
DISCUSSION
The features like severe chest pain radiating to the jaw and back associated with breathlessness and sweating in Vikshepika is indicative of acute coronary syndrome. Cyanosis indicates the failing heart. Altered consciousness is due to the reduced forward flow to the brain. Now a days it can be diagnosed early with electrocardiography and echocardiography and by evaluation of troponins. In the disease ‘Aayamika’, there is chamber enlargement of the heart. The cause of cardiac dilatation includes, valvular heart diseases, congenital heart diseases. The syndrome of Ayamika is indicative of heart failure. Dyspnoea is due to pulmonary congestion. Giddiness, syncope, weakness are due to reduction in forward flow. Anorexia and ascites are features of hepatic and portal congestion due to back pressure. Treatment is of the underlying cause and resultant heart failure and aimed towards improving cardiac function. The disease Kausthik resemble the modern infective endocarditis. Infective endocarditis is a microbial infection of heart valves or the endocardium in proximity to congenital or acquired cardiac defects. Infection of the endothelial linings of arterial aneurysms or AV fistula produces a similar illness. Streptococcus viridians is the most common infecting organism. These organisms are the part of the bacterial flora of the pharynx and upper respiratory tract and the infection may follow dental extraction, tonsillectomy or bronchoscopy. Staphylococcus aureus may cause subacute endocarditis (SBE) and is responsible for 50% of the acute forms. Patients with CVP line for parentral feeding, temporary pacemaker are prone to this infection. Cellulitis or abscess are also the source of infection. Enterococcus fecalis is commonly found in elderly with prostatic disease. In women with UTI or after pelvic surgery. Staphylococcus epidermis, histoplasma, brucella, candida and aspergillus infections with these organisms is commonly found in IV drug addicts, alcoholics and patients with prosthetic valves [8]. The disease Aavarnika is the pericardial effusion from modern perspective. Pericardial effusion refers to the collection of exudates in pericardial sac. It may occur post MI, renal failure, tuberculosis. Acute stage is dry and fibrinous later effusion collects in closed pericardium. When pericardium can no more distend, produces mechanical embrassment causing inadequate ventricular filling. This is tamponade. The disease Parikshaya mentioned in Ayurved Vigyan, refers to the cardiac atrophy which is a decrease in the size, strength, weight, and activity of the heart. Atrophy of a cardiac muscle generally develops at senile age and is called as a physiological atrophy. Acute shortage of proteins, carbohydrates, vitamins and various microcells is observed that also leads to development of a miocardiodistrofiya. At pathological processes of infectious character, food poisonings, abuses of alcohol are the main reason for pathological changes in a cardiac muscle changes. The excessive constant physical overstrain too is considered an important factor in development of an atrophy of a myocardium, especially at persons of young age. Because of the strengthened expense of reserve opportunities of muscles there is their fast wear. General cardiac atrophy may arise from causes that impair or interfere with the nutrition of the body, the heart sharing in the general atrophy, cancer of the stomach, phthisis pulmonalis, long suppurative processes, Bright's disease, etc., being examples. Partial obstruction of the coronary arteries may give rise to atrophy by impairing the heart's nutrition. The clinical picture differs at different patients because of the reasons of emergence of an atrophy of a myocardium and existence of associated diseases. If process is compensated, symptoms may not appear for several years. Emergence and development of an illness can begin at any age. Patient may complain easy fatiguability, exertional dyspnoea, syncope. Features of heart failure may occur. The disease ‘Medasutram’ mentioned in ‘Ayurved Vigyan’ refers to the fatty degeneration of the heart. Fatty degeneration of the heart is a retrogressive condition in which fat droplets are found in the myocardial sarcoplasm. It is usually secondary to such conditions as myocarditis, pericarditis, coronary arteriosclerosis, myocardial insufficiency, starvation, anemia, fever, phosphorus or arsenic poisoning, diphtheria, scarlet fever, typhoid fever and various other diseases but has been noted to occur without any demonstrable cause. The condition is common, especially in minor degrees. Diffuse fatty degeneration occurs in the senile heart, or in coronary artery disease [9]. A decade ago this condition was more frequently diagnosed than it is now. Opinion is divided over considering fatty degeneration of the heart as a cause of sudden death. The current opinion is that fatty infiltration into the myocardium (lipomatosis or cor adiposum) rarely affects cardiac function. This may not be entirely true. Rupture during acute myocardial infarction has certainly been shown to be more common in the fatty heart. In the year 2018 study by Dr.Shailesh Pitale and Dr. Anagha Sahastrabuddhe from Nagpur in their presentation at world heart congress, Amsterdam, showed that epicardial fat is responsible for the coronary artery disease. After deep study they found that the markers for monocytes chemoattractant protein -1 gene (MCPI1) are more expressive in peoples with CAD. In such patients monocytes are recruited and they release markers which attract the foam cells in arteries to cause blockages. They also found that blockages were found in the coronary arteries which were surrounded by epicardial fat.[10]
The heart disease ‘Pruthuka” mentioned in ‘Ayurved Vigyan’ refers to the hypertrophy of the heart. The cardiomyopathies are a group of chronic heart muscle disorder of unknown cause. Common causes of specific heart muscle disease includes cardiovascular causes like CAD, hypertension, chronic valvular disease. Infective causes like Influenza, varicella, mumps, herpes simplex, Coxackie virus, protozoal (Chaga’s disease). Metabolic causes like Kwashiorkar, Thiamine deficiency (beriberi). Endocrine causes like Thyrotoxicosis, myxoedema, diabetes mellitus. Toxic causes like Alcohol, cytotoxic drugs (danorubicin). Neuromuscular causes like Muscular dystrophy, Freidreich’s ataxia. Connective tissue causes like SLE, polyarteritis nodosa. Infiltrative causes like Sarcoidosis, neoplastic, hemochromatosis.
Conclusions
1] The disease Vikshepika described in Ayurved Vigyan book resembles acute coronary syndrome from modern perspective.
2] The disease Aayamika described in Ayurved Vigyan book resembles heart failure syndrome from modern perspective.
3] The disease Pruthuka described in Ayurved Vigyan book resembles hypertrophic cardiomyopathy from modern perspective.
4] The disease Kausthika described in Ayurved Vigyan book resembles infective endocarditis from modern perspective.
5] The disease Aavarnika described in Ayurved Vigyan book resembles pericardial effusion from modern perspective.
6] The disease Medasutram described in Ayurved Vigyan book resembles fatty degeneration of heart from modern perspective.
7] The disease Parikshaya described in Ayurved Vigyan book resembles acute cardiac degeneration from modern perspective.
References
- Vinodlal Sen, (2012) Ayurved Vigyan, chapter 16, reprint edition, published by Vasu Publications, Shaktinagar, Delhi-110 007, 122
View at Publisher | View at Google Scholar - Vinodlal Sen, (2012) Ayurved Vigyan, chapter 16,, reprint edition, published by Vasu Publications, Shaktinagar, Delhi-110 007, 122
View at Publisher | View at Google Scholar - Vinodlal Sen, (2012) Ayurved Vigyan, chapter 16, reprint edition, published by Vasu Publications, Shaktinagar, Delhi-110 007, 122
View at Publisher | View at Google Scholar - Vinodlal Sen, (2012) Ayurved Vigyan, chapter 16, reprint edition, published by Vasu Publications, Shaktinagar, Delhi-110 007, 122
View at Publisher | View at Google Scholar - Vinodlal Sen, (2012) Ayurved Vigyan, chapter 16, reprint edition, published by Vasu Publications, Shaktinagar, Delhi-110 007, 123
View at Publisher | View at Google Scholar - Vinodlal Sen, Ayurved Vigyan, (2012) chapter 16, reprint edition, published by Vasu Publications, Shaktinagar, Delhi-110 007, 123
View at Publisher | View at Google Scholar - Vinodlal Sen, Ayurved Vigyan, (2012) chapter 16, reprint edition, published by Vasu Publications, Shaktinagar, Delhi-110 007, 123
View at Publisher | View at Google Scholar - Praveen Kumar and Michael Clark, (2017) Clinical Medicine’ chapter 23,9th edition , published by Elsevier Ltd., 931-1021
View at Publisher | View at Google Scholar - Bilheimer DW, Buja LM,Parkey RW, et al. (1978) Fatty acid accumulation and abnormal lipid deposition in peripheral and border zones of experimental myocardial infarcts. J Nucl Med 19:276–283.
View at Publisher | View at Google Scholar - Dr.Shailesh Pitale and Dr. Anagha Sahastrabuddhe, (2018) Epicardial fat responsible for coronary artery disease- case studies, news daily “The Hitvada”, Monday 28th May.
View at Publisher | View at Google Scholar