Advertisement

A Study on the Reduction of Airborne Microbial Bioaerosols at Indoor air of Hospital’s Intensive Care Unit by Using Novel Air Filtration and UV Irradiation Technology

Review Article | DOI: https://doi.org/10.31579/crr-2022/036

A Study on the Reduction of Airborne Microbial Bioaerosols at Indoor air of Hospital’s Intensive Care Unit by Using Novel Air Filtration and UV Irradiation Technology

  • Ioannis Rabias 1*
  • Drosos Kourounis 1
  • Nikoleta Bobolaki 1
  • Nikolaos V. Sipsas 2
  • Yanna K. Atanasova 3
  • George K. Nicolaides 3
  • Maria Evangelidou 4

1 Quality ControlDepartment, Hellenic PasteurInstitute, Athens, Greece.

2 Infectious Diseases Unit, Pathophysiology Department, Laikon General Hospital and National and Kapodistrian University of Athens - Athens, Greece.

3 Department of Mechanical Engineering and Department of Civil Engineering, University of West Attika, Aegaleo,Greece.

4 Diagnostic Department, Hellenic Pasteur Institute, Athens, Greece.

*Corresponding Author: Ioannis Rabias. Quality Control Department, Hellenic Pasteur Institute, Athens, Greece.

Citation: © 2024, Ioannis Rabias, This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Copyright: Ioannis Rabias, Drosos Kourounis, Nikoleta Bobolaki, Maria Evangelidou, Nikolaos V. Sipsas, Ioannis Rabias, (2024). A study on the Reduction of Airborne Microbial Bioaerosols at indoor air of hospital’s Intensive Care Unit by using Novel Air Filtration and UV Irradiation Technology, Clinical Research and Reviews,3(6); DOI:10.31579/crr-2022/036

Received: 18 October 2024 | Accepted: 28 December 2024 | Published: 05 November 2024

Keywords: real time reduction of airborne bioaerosols; air filtration; uvc-ultrapure technology

Abstract

The monitoring of microbial quality and quantity of indoor air in Intensive Care Units is important to make progress at controlling nosocomial infections. This study’s aim was to monitor the presence of pathogenicbacteria and fungi inside an operating Intensive Care Unit and to observe the real-time microbial reduction caused by the application of a prototype air filtration-UV irradiation sterilization device. Air samples of the indoor air of a hospital’s ICU operating room were taken using air sampler technology at opposing sampling spots. The colony formed units were counted, then isolated for the purposes of PCR and molecularsequencing procedures. The microbial burden recovered from the initial sampling was counted at 141 cfu/m3 regarding the bacterial colonies, with species and sub  species of Pantoea, Priestia, and Bacillus genre havin a dominant presence. As for the fungi, 112 cfu/m3 were counted, mainly from the Mucor and Aspergillus family. The testing of prototype UVC-ULTRAPURE displayed particularly promising results on the reduction of active airborne microbial particles, with the sterilization success rate beingup to 70%, within 1 hour of the device’sperformance. The need of microbial monitoring in regular basis, inside hospital rooms should be considered, as patients are prone to secondary infections. Future research and surveillance assessing the importance of UVC radiation technology in terminating pathogens.

Introduction

At a worldwidepandemic such as COVID-19, bacteriaand fungi are reported to cause co infections to critically ill patients, which increases morbidity and mortality of the virus [1,2]. Airborne viruses, bacteria, and fungi spores usuallyexist in the form of Bioaerosols. A bio aerosol is an airbornecollection of biological materials. Ubiquitous indoors and out, bio-aerosols in suspended, aerosolized liquid droplets typically contain microbes, like viruses, bacteria and fungi combined with byproducts of cellular metabolism. Inhalation of microbial aerosols can elicitadverse human healtheffects including infection, allergic reaction, inflammation, and respiratory disease [3]. Hospitalization in ICU is highly associated with microbial infections, leading particularly, to ventilator-associated pneumonia (VAP) and bloodstream infections (BSI) [4]. Furthermore, it is observedthat within the first few days after virus infection, critically ill patients often develop respiratory tract distortion or pulmonary dysbiosis, which can furtherprogress into a secondary bacterialor fungal infection just a few weeks later[5]. The rapid and accurate identification of bacteria or fungi, that present as pathogenic or resident microorganisms inside hospital wards, during the period of COVID-19 should be an important step towards the management of patients, especially when there are several published papers [6, 7, 8] which claim, that bacteria and fungi can act as vessels for viruses and by doing so, these microorganisms can demonstrate a coinfection ability (aiming their own proliferation) or can act supportively to virus’s transmission. Another crucial factor for the reduction of the virus’s spread is the de-contamination of the hospital’s Covid-ward indoor air, by means which do not harm the patientand also do not impedethe daily routineof the personnel. In this work we performed a two-scale experimental procedure, which aim was to initially identify the genre of the microbial load inside a hospital’s Intensive Care Unit and furthermore, to investigate the decontamination potential of a prototype air sterilization device,UVC ULTRAPURE, invented at the Department of Mechanical Engineering at the University of West Attica Greece.The device’s operating principle is basedon the fact that pathogens are being captured on the surface of a wide angle (WA) HEPA FILTER, where this new type of HEPA filter has the capacity to restrain 99.7% of pathogens (bacteria, fungi, and virus etc.) due to the 0.1 to 0.3 micrometer (μm) size of WA HEPA filter holes. It is worth to mention that the size of virus particlesis at the scale of 0.1μm, but they are present almostalways within larger droplets (>0.1μm), generated by infected hosts and therefore almost always contained by (WA) HepaFilter. Contrary to a regular HEPA filter which has dense folds, WA HEPA filter has larger angle between foldsto avoid the creation of shading effectsduring its irradiation and therefore its entire surfacecan be continuously UV irradiated. Furthermore, the irradiation is also being reinforced by a quartz grid –opticalgrating which createsa multi – focus effectof UV light on boththe surface and holes of HEPA through an optical multi diffraction effect. The capture of microorganisms and the subsequent UV continuous irradiation results in the total distraction of pathogen’s organicmaterial without leavingbehind any organicresidues on the filter. Consequently, any saturation of the filterwill be due only to inorganic material (i.e., dust), thus eliminating the health risk related with the handlingof filter replacement and disposal. The need for search for a better UV technology air sterilizer aroused after realizing that most of the devices that are available in the market using UV irradiation for pathogen neutralization and destruction are using the technique of irradiating an air stream which passes through the device and contains these pathogens. According though to published results, the dwelt time of pathogens in the irradiated zone for these devices is extremely small,thus the UV radiation doesn’thave the necessary time to kill these pathogens. To the contrary,the proposed new technology is not based on the irradiation of an air stream, but instead on the capturing first of the pathogens on a flat WA HEPA filter surface and subsequently through intense and continuous multi focused irradiation, eliminates them.

 

Methods

Monitoring of Microbial Load.

The microbial load’sidentification process consistsof several steps, starting with air sampling from the hospital’s ward space, which had a size of approximately 90 m3 and was occupiedby 2 patients at their recovery phase.Through air sampling, it is possible to evaluate microbial contamination in environments with considerable risk of infection. Microbial load measurements with air samplers are performed in accordance with the EU GMP for proper manufacturing principles for microbialmonitoring of ambient air in controlled environments up to clean rooms [9]. The site’s microbial load was measured by using MAS-100 air sampler (Figure 1), which consists of a radial fan, controlled by a flow sensor, that accurately regulates the real time air flow at 100 liters/min for a 10 min time interval. A specified amount of air is aspirated through a perforated lid and impacted onto the surface of growth media inside a 90-100 mm Petri dish. This procedure is called ‘active air monitoring’, in contrast with ‘passive air monitoring’, where the sampling is performed throughgravity force only and is a more time-consuming technique[10].

Figure 1: The MAS-100 air samplerand Petri dishes positioning on the room and sampling.

Two types of Petri dishes are used (Figure.1), one that containsTSA (Tryptone soya agar) growth medium for bacteria promotion and another with SAB (Sabouraud agar) medium for fungi promotion. After the standardPetri dish’s incubation time (according to ISO 14698-1 instructions), the results found regarding the number of bacteria or fungi, are expressed in cfu (colony forming units) / m3. For a better estimation of the microbial load inside the ICU, air samples were taken in two distinct spots, the first one locating between the patient’s head high and the second one at the room’s center (Figure 2).

 

 

Figure 2: Graphical representation of the Intensive Care Unit (ICU). The air sterilizing device (silver) filtrates air input (red) through WA HEPA, radiates it with UVC and air output (green) is released back in the room.

All doors and windows were kept locked during the sampling, in order to keep theexperiment conditions unaltered from exterior factors Decontamination Potential of a Prototype Air Sterilization Device UVC ULTRAPURE, as the device is called, can filtrate air and apply UVC radiation using a novel patterned technique. The air passes through HEPA 13 filters, which have the ability of retaining microbial particles [13]. These particles are subsequently UVC irradiated, a procedure that can kill most ofthe retained microbes [14] and moreover, the emitted radiation does not encounterindividuals around it, because of the device’ssteel plated protection. Herein we evaluated the performance of UVC ULTRAPURE prototype, which apply cutting edge technologies, mentioned in the above references. The second scale of this work was to examine the sterilization potential of UVC ULTRAPURE, inside a rather contaminated environment, as an ICU theoretically is and at real life conditions (patients inside experimental area) betweentwo different time points, 30 and 60 min after the device’sapplication. These 30-minute interval between measurements was decided upon the fact that each measurement takes approximately 10 minutes to complete. As in the first sampling, two distinct sampling spots were used, specimens for TSA and Sabouraud plates were taken and also all doors and windowswere kept shut.Following the samplingprocedure, the plates were incubated at the appropriate conditions (32.5 °C for TSA plates and 22.5 °C for SAB).

Molecular Identification

The last step of the experiment’s procedurewas to identify the genre of thesemicrobial colonies and by doing so to have an estimation of the microorganism’s pathogenicity, which ifexisting, has a crucial effecton the patient’s health and recovery. To achieve that, single colonies from agar plates were isolated and diluted in 2ml PBS, so that to be processed for DNA extraction using the Mag Core automated nucleic acid extractor, according to the manufacturer’s protocol. DNA samples extracted from the TSA and Sabouraud agar plates were subjected to Polymerase Chain Reaction using primers targetingthe 16S ribosomal RNA and 18S ribosomalRNA respectively. PCR products were analyzed using the QIAxcel Advanced System. All three DNA samples extracted from TSA agar plates colonies were found positive for 16S ribosomal RNA and 2 out of 5 DNA samples extracted from Sabouraud agar plates colonies were found positive for 18S ribosomal RNA. Once validated, the PCR products were purified using the QIAquick PCR purification kit according to the manufacturer’s protocol. DNA concentration was measured using the Nanodrop spectrophotometer. Sanger sequencing was performed in 120-150 ngr/ reaction of DNA using the internal primers 536F, 536R, 800F, 800R, 1050F and 1050R for 16S ribosomal RNA as previously described and the NS5F, NS6R for the 18S ribosomal RNA. Sequencing data were processedusing the BioEditSoftware and consensussequences were analyzedby BLAST, with over 90% successful identification rate for each of the isolated microbial colonies that were recovered.

Results

At the end of incubation period the number of microorganisms before and after the application of the prototype device was recorded and also the percentage for the reductionof microorganisms due to the use of the sterilization system,was measured. From the mean values of sampling, came the followingresults of air samplesmeasurements (Figure.3).

 

Figure 3: Representation of the reduction of counted colonies and of ?u’s reduction as sterilization time proceeds (cfu/time) by air samples Measurements of bacterial and fungal coloniescounted at standardtime points beforeand after device’sapplication.

Specifically, it was found that the device contributed to a 70.21% reduction in bacterial load, as well as a 67.85%reduction in fungalload. At this point, it is worth mentioning that our initial measurements (before the application of the sterilization system)present to us a spacewith a fairly heavy microbial load, as for both bacteria and fungi more than 100 cfu / plate were retrieved for 1 m3 of air sample. After 1 hour of the device’s application and with 4 people always present inside the room (2 patients and 2 research analysts) one can observe that the sterilization system proceeds to a steadilyreduction of the air’s microbial load. According to the number of cfu/m3 that were recovered from the sampling procedure, it is safe to claim that the ICU’s microbial load was relatively high, in relation to clean room standards for GMP (Good Manufacturing Practice), which is justified when patient’s contamination biomaterial is constantly spreading inside the room. Τhe results from BLAST sequencing which came out, showedthat the recoveredcolonies from samplingbelonged to the following genera-species of bacteria and fungi(Table 1 and Table 2).

Bacterial colonies

  • Pantoea agglomerans
  • Priestia flexa
  • Pantoea vagans
  • Neobacillus ginsengisoli
  • Pantoea deleyi
  • Bacillus halotolerans
  • Priestia megaterium
  • Bacillus mojavensis
  • Priestia aryabhattai
  • Bacillus subtilis
  • Priestia qingshengii
 

Table 1: Genera-Species of Bacteria from the recovered Coloniesof Sampling.

The habitat of the recoveredbacterial species is placed either in the microfauna of the human digestive system, or in the external environment (comingfrom the soil) or foundin certain foods (such as vegetables). Due to the nature of the experimental field (ICU unit), it was considered necessary to examine the pathogenicity of the identified microorganisms in the human immunological system. As previously mentioned, among the bacterial genera recovered there were several species-representatives of the genus Pantoea, which [11] are potentially pathogenic in immunocompromised patients.Examining the rest of the bacterial genera(Priestia, Neobacillus and Bacillus) no specific reference to the existence of pathogenicity was found, but this does not exclude the occurrence of pathogenicity in case of an overpopulation of thesaid bacterial genera.

Fungal colonies

  • Mucor lanceolatus
  • Mucor janssenii
  • Mucor circinelloides
  • Mucor griseocyanus
  • Mucor racemosus
  • Circinella simplex
  • Mucor spinosus
  • Aspergillus niger(or

brasilliensis)

Table 2: genera-species of fungi from the recovered colonies of sampling.

The fungal genera-species that were recovered are all microorganisms of wide and even global distribution, coming mainly from food, from the microbiome of the humanskin, or from the externalenvironment. Regarding theirpotential pathogenicity, the genus Aspergillus [12], in specificconditions of aspiration of large amountsof spores of the fungus,can lead to the appearance of aspergillosis, a serious disease of the respiratory system. The species of the genus Mucor do not show pathogenicity in humans, due to their lack of ability to reproduce at 36-37 ºC, apart from some thermo- resistantstrains, which were not found in the fungi we examined.

Discussion

Admittedly, this study faced limitations regarding the repeatability of results, which can be justified due to bureaucratic issues that made it difficult torepeat the experiment. The aim of this study, as mentioned above, was to initiallyperform a monitoring of microbiological materialinside an ICU and furthermore to assess the sterilization potentialof UVC ULTRAPURE device. As for the first step, the results from the air sampling indicate that insidethe ICU the microbial load was relatively high, something that can be justified from the existenceof 2 patients inside the room. Althoughthe hospital’s personnel made efforts to keep the environment clean with daily cleaning procedures, the continuous emission of biological material from the patients and the importation of microbes from external environment, kept the bioburden at high values.According to the molecular sequencing of colonies recovered from TSA and SAB plates,a range of potential pathogenic bacteria and fungi was found,which can (underspecific circumstances) have a severeimpact on the immune systemof already immunosuppressed patients. Those findings strengthen the opinion that the conventional means of cleaning are insufficient and extra sterilizing of the ICU is indeed needed.

 

Conclusion

The prototype UVC ULTRAPURE sterilization device had undergonebefore similar testing inside areas of public interest (classroom, bus, metro) with worth mentioning results, achieving microbial reduction at a range of 45 up to 93% within 30 minutes of system’s application [15]. In this work the device was evaluated inside a specific nosocomial area (ICU) with continuous feedback of biological matter coming from the patients and the results were once more encouraging with an estimated reduction up to 70% within 60 minutes of usage. These results imply that, despitethe presence of patients and the personnel conducting the experiment, the device has a sterilization potency which is not hindered by the emission of an amount of biological matter inside the experimental zone.

 

Author Contributions:

 All authors have contributed to this work equally, both in the execution of the experiment and in the writing process.

Acknowledgements:

 Thankingfor the official cooperation Mr. Fanis Roides,President of Administration Board of the General University Hospital "LAIKO"-Athens Greece.

Conflicts of Interest: 

“The authors declareno conflict of interest.

References

Clinical Trials and Clinical Research: I am delighted to provide a testimonial for the peer review process, support from the editorial office, and the exceptional quality of the journal for my article entitled “Effect of Traditional Moxibustion in Assisting the Rehabilitation of Stroke Patients.” The peer review process for my article was rigorous and thorough, ensuring that only high-quality research is published in the journal. The reviewers provided valuable feedback and constructive criticism that greatly improved the clarity and scientific rigor of my study. Their expertise and attention to detail helped me refine my research methodology and strengthen the overall impact of my findings. I would also like to express my gratitude for the exceptional support I received from the editorial office throughout the publication process. The editorial team was prompt, professional, and highly responsive to all my queries and concerns. Their guidance and assistance were instrumental in navigating the submission and revision process, making it a seamless and efficient experience. Furthermore, I am impressed by the outstanding quality of the journal itself. The journal’s commitment to publishing cutting-edge research in the field of stroke rehabilitation is evident in the diverse range of articles it features. The journal consistently upholds rigorous scientific standards, ensuring that only the most impactful and innovative studies are published. This commitment to excellence has undoubtedly contributed to the journal’s reputation as a leading platform for stroke rehabilitation research. In conclusion, I am extremely satisfied with the peer review process, the support from the editorial office, and the overall quality of the journal for my article. I wholeheartedly recommend this journal to researchers and clinicians interested in stroke rehabilitation and related fields. The journal’s dedication to scientific rigor, coupled with the exceptional support provided by the editorial office, makes it an invaluable platform for disseminating research and advancing the field.

img

Dr Shiming Tang

Clinical Reviews and Case Reports, The comment form the peer-review were satisfactory. I will cements on the quality of the journal when I receive my hardback copy

img

Hameed khan